Submit a Review
  • 5 stars
    11
  • 4 stars
    0
  • 3 stars
    0
  • 2 stars
    0
  • 1 stars
    0

5 out of 5 based on 21 ratings.
1 user reviews.
Includes 10 Zillow reviews
Photo of Maria Caifa
Maria Caifa

I have known Maria for many years, first as a friend and later as both my friend and real estate agent. She guided me through two home sales and purchases and did an outstanding job. Maria is always available to her clients and is an expert at hand-holding which some of us need a lot of.

Jan 26, 2026

Maria was amazing to work with. She understood our need to sell quickly and for the best price and through her expertise, she delivered. She sold the house inn6 days and $71,000 over asking. She was supportive through the entire process and so compassionate knowing we were selling our childhood home after my mom’s passing. She was very responsive to all our questions and concerns with professionalism, and was considerate of my work hours often calling me on my way to or from work so as to not interrupt my workday. I highly recommend Maria for all your real estate needs.

Jan 01, 2026

We had a great experience working with Maria to sell our home. Maria has extensive knowledge of the local market and really kept us in the loop during the entire selling process. Her marketing plan was top-notch, and she ensured everything went smoothly up to closing. If you’re looking for a dedicated and professional realtor to help sell your home, I highly recommend Maria Caifa.

Dec 19, 2025

Highly Recommend Maria — An Incredible Realtor!Maria was absolutely amazing to work with! She sold our home in Port Jefferson Station in such a short amount of time and made the entire process feel effortless. From the very first meeting, she came prepared, confident, and full of valuable insight about the market.Her professionalism, warmth, and dedication stood out every step of the way. She guided us through staging, showings, and negotiations with such ease — always keeping us informed and supported. Maria truly went above and beyond to make sure everything went smoothly, and her positivity made what could have been a stressful experience feel exciting and rewarding.If you’re thinking about selling your home, Maria is the realtor you want in your corner. We couldn’t be happier with the results and are so grateful for her hard work and heart.

Nov 06, 2025

Maria did a great job, we were very satisfied. Very knowledgeable and was always available to answer any questions we had. Her suggestions were also very helpful. Such as referrals of a Lawyer and moving company.

Nov 05, 2025

Maria was fabulous to work with. She is kind, easy to talk to, knowledgeable and very helpful. She helped us with our sale and our purchase and did everything she could to make the process as seamless as possible. I highly recommend Maria and would absolutely use her again in the future.

Oct 17, 2025

Maria was an absolute pleasure to work with! She’s extremely professional. She was very responsive to calls, texts and emails. She will always advocate for her clients when needed. Maria helped us w buying our forever home and selling our condo. Thank you Maria!!’

Oct 08, 2025

Maria was extremely helpful and patient throughout our home buying process. I was most impressed by her timely responses to voice mail and texts. I highly recommend her.

Sep 03, 2025

Maria was great! We are first time homebuyers and she helped us navigate a challenging transaction with ease. She has an extensive network of contacts who can help with any issue that might arise and she is an excellent negotiator who will advocate for you throughout the entire homebuying process. Thanks Maria!

Joe Fiola
Jun 25, 2025

We wanted to take a moment to thank Maria C. of the Bryan Karp Team for all of her amazing work & dedication that she put in to lead us up to the perfect opportunity to sell our home.We are extremely thankful for everything that she did for us from keeping us in the loop every step of the way & helping us navigate thru the selling process from start to finish.We had an amazing experience & we are thankful of Maria for being there every step of the way.Many thanks & all the best from all of us.

Mar 03, 2025

We are very pleased with the service that we received from Maria C she couldn’t have been more professional with a personal touch throughout the whole process of selling our home We will definitely be recommending her and Coldwell Banker American Homes to our friends and family for all their real estate needs The Okerblom’s

Margaret Okerblom
Sep 21, 2024

Share Your Experience

The experience you've had in working with me is important. Please take a few moments and share how your experience was so I can share it with others.

Review Submission Form
  • Markets:
  • 1 Stars2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars

Login to My Homefinder

Pixel